- ISPA has called for an evidence-based assessment of the human rights implications of South Africa’s expanding data centre industry in its submission to the SAHRC.
- The SAHRC launched its inquiry into the human rights implications of data centres and digital infrastructure with a public call for submissions in May 2026.
- ISPA says South African data centre developers must comply with the same environmental, planning, water, heritage, licensing and energy regulations as other infrastructure developers.
- ISPA argues that local data centre energy and water consumption should be assessed using South African evidence rather than figures imported from markets such as the United States.
- ISPA says locally based data centres can support digital sovereignty, economic development, cybersecurity and freedom of expression by strengthening South Africa’s domestic digital infrastructure. *
The backlash against the rapid expansion of data centres is gaining political momentum internationally. In the United States, Texas governor-elect Gina Hinojosa has pledged to halt approvals for new data centres until legislation is introduced to protect communities, marking a significant shift in one of the country’s biggest markets for AI infrastructure.
Hinojosa, who defeated incumbent Greg Abbott in the 3 November election, made the proposed moratorium a central campaign promise, alongside commitments to end tax incentives for data centre developers and give local communities a greater say in proposed developments. Her victory has cast uncertainty over billions of dollars in planned data centre investment in the state.
The result also drew a pointed response from Elon Musk, who had backed Abbott. “Data centers in space looking pretty appealing right now,” he posted on X.
The Texas election reflects growing public concern about the electricity and water demands of data centres, as well as their impact on local communities. Similar opposition is emerging in other markets as governments and communities grapple with the infrastructure demands of the AI boom.
The South African situation
South Africa is now confronting its own debate about the expansion of data centres and their implications for human rights, resource consumption and economic development.
The South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) issued a call for public submissions in May 2026 on the human rights implications of data centres and digital infrastructure. The Internet Service Providers’ Association (ISPA) has welcomed the inquiry, arguing that the debate needs to be informed by evidence rather than assumptions imported from other markets.
The Internet Service Providers’ Association (ISPA) has called for an evidence-based approach to assessing the human rights implications of South Africa’s expanding data centre industry, arguing that economic development and the protection of fundamental rights should not be treated as competing priorities.
In a submission to the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC), ISPA has expressed support for the commission’s inquiry into the human rights implications of data centres and digital infrastructure. The inquiry follows a call for public submissions issued in May 2026.
Local evidence
ISPA, which is officially recognised by the Department of Communications and Digital Technologies (DCDT) as South Africa’s internet industry representative body, says the debate should be informed by local evidence rather than assumptions drawn from international markets.
“Let’s establish the facts and use them to figure out an evidence-based balance between socioeconomic development and observing fundamental rights, and growth and the economy,” says Dominic Cull, ISPA regulatory advisor.
The submission comes as government increasingly positions data centres as strategic infrastructure for economic growth and digital transformation. The National Data and Cloud Policy, together with announced plans for state investment in cloud infrastructure, reflects the role government sees for the sector in building a modern, re-industrialised economy.
ISPA argues that data centre developers are subject to the same environmental, planning, heritage, water, licensing and energy requirements as other infrastructure developers. It rejects suggestions that the industry benefits from special regulatory exemptions.
The association also points to its ongoing engagement with local data centre operators, saying many demonstrate corporate citizenship and environmental stewardship standards that exceed existing legal requirements.
Electricity and water use under scrutiny
Electricity and water consumption have become central to concerns about the industry’s rapid expansion. ISPA argues, however, that much of the information circulating in public debate is based on data from markets such as the United States, whose energy and water environments differ significantly from South Africa’s.
While acknowledging that data centres are energy-intensive, ISPA says their operational efficiency makes it advantageous to consolidate computing capacity in modern facilities rather than rely on dispersed, legacy IT infrastructure.
The association also argues that growing data centre investment could provide more predictable electricity demand at a time when increased renewable energy generation and other factors are changing the country’s energy landscape.
It contends that additional industrial demand could help support electricity system economics and potentially moderate price increases for consumers. This remains dependent on the broader dynamics of electricity supply, demand and pricing.
On water, ISPA says operators have a commercial incentive to minimise consumption and are continually refining technologies to improve efficiency. It maintains that local data centre water usage is being driven below global averages, although the submission does not provide comparative consumption figures.
Data centres and digital sovereignty
Beyond resource consumption, ISPA argues that locally hosted data centres have an important role in protecting South Africa’s digital sovereignty.
It says infrastructure located within the country’s borders can strengthen its ability to respond to cyberattacks, disinformation campaigns and economic pressure from foreign actors. The association also links locally hosted digital infrastructure to the protection of democracy and the freedom of expression enabled by internet access.
Although ISPA does not own or operate data centres, its members rely on them to deliver internet services. The association says this gives the industry a direct interest in the outcome of the SAHRC inquiry.
“South Africa has an impressive track-record of polar opposites finding the middle ground in the best interests of the country. ISPA is confident the data centre debate will be settled as reasonable South Africans find each other, as always,” says Cull.
ISPA advocates for an open, free and competitive internet landscape. More information is available at www.ispa.org.za.
* Summary created by AI









