• Subscribe to our newsletter
The Media Online
  • Home
  • MOST Awards
  • News
    • Awards
    • Media Mecca
  • Print
    • Newspapers
    • Magazines
    • Publishing
  • Broadcasting
    • TV
    • Radio
    • Cinema
    • Video
  • Digital
    • Mobile
    • Online
  • Agencies
    • Advertising
    • Media agency
    • Public Relations
  • OOH
    • Events
  • Research & Education
    • Research
    • Media Education
      • Media Mentor
  • Press Office
    • Press Office
    • TMO.Live Blog
    • Events
    • Jobs
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • MOST Awards
  • News
    • Awards
    • Media Mecca
  • Print
    • Newspapers
    • Magazines
    • Publishing
  • Broadcasting
    • TV
    • Radio
    • Cinema
    • Video
  • Digital
    • Mobile
    • Online
  • Agencies
    • Advertising
    • Media agency
    • Public Relations
  • OOH
    • Events
  • Research & Education
    • Research
    • Media Education
      • Media Mentor
  • Press Office
    • Press Office
    • TMO.Live Blog
    • Events
    • Jobs
No Result
View All Result
The Media Online
No Result
View All Result
Home Press

Marikana massacre: How South African journalism failed the test

by Ylva Rodny-Gumede
November 25, 2015
in Press
0 0
0
Marikana massacre: How South African journalism failed the test
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Different narratives have emerged from media coverage of what happened in the build up to the Marikana massacre, what occurred on the day and what transpired afterwards. The same goes for why it happened and who was to blame.

My study of the coverage shows that mainstream news media displayed a bias towards official explanations of what happened and who was to blame in the days leading up to the massacre and the week afterwards.

The massacre of the 34 striking Lonmin miners by police on 16 August 2012, is the worst act of violence by the South African police since the end of apartheid in 1994. Ten other people – eight nonstriking workers and two policemen – died during strike-related violence at the mine in the North West province.

I conclude that the reporting of the massacre was characterised by embedded journalism, sensationalised coverage and polarisation of views and stakeholders. This was particularly true when it came to coverage of the two main mining unions – the Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union (Amcu) and the National Union of Mineworkers (NUM).

The coverage neglected to factor in alternative views, including those of the protesting miners themselves. Instead, the news media became a loudspeaker for powerful interests in the South African political and social-economic nexus, neglecting fundamental problems underlining labour relations in South Africa. Journalists trumped up conflicts and polarisations, further exacerbating rifts between the various stakeholders.

By and large, the journalistic principles of fairness, balance, truth and ethics were neglected. This includes coverage in the lead up to, and in the immediate aftermath of, the massacre.

As such is it legitimate to ask:

  • Did South African journalists simply not do their job properly in the days leading up to the massacre and the subsequent week?
  • Do South African journalists have a poor understanding of conflict reporting? and
  • What, if anything, changed as the truth of the massacre started to emerge?

Coverage of the massacre and its aftermath

A close reading of 162 articles published by major publications between 12 August and 23 August and a viewing of 24 news bulletins, shows there was a clear focus on the violence displayed by the protesters, fuelled by witchcraft. Although true, over-emphasising the use of witchcraft played into stereotypes of Africans as irrational and backwards, ideas cemented by the erstwhile apartheid regime.

Less attention was paid to the brutality displayed by the police. Research also shows that there was a lack of female sources as well as sources emanating directly from the affected families and broader mining community.

Overall, the South African mainstream news media created a rather limited, if not distorted, view of what happened at Marikana. In this sense the news coverage conformed to what has been labelled “war reporting”. This is defined by the way journalists and war correspondents cover conflicts with an emphasis on violence, suffering and sensationalism, while polarising view points and oversimplifying the underlying causes of conflict.

Analysing the coverage of the Farlam Commission inquiry and the release of its report nearly three years after the massacre suggests there was an attempt to get a broader set of voices in news coverage. But this seemed to be more as an afterthought than a real commitment to having diverse views.

Everyone in the mainstream media also appeared to have simply followed one other. Supposedly competing news outlets echoed the same stories. While some media outlets tried their best, others were mere followers. As such, while segments of the print news media did a pretty good job in some instances, the broadcast media, and television in particular, insensitively played the same horrifying footage over and over again.

Interestingly, both the public broadcaster, the SABC, and free-to-air channel e.tv, have yet to screen Rehad Desai’s award-winning Marikana documentary, Miners Shot Down, despite popular demand for it to be shown.

In the reporting on the Farlam Commission, little space was given to contextualisation. Neither the broadcast or print media gave much space to the nuance and the context in which facts were being established. Overall, the news coverage focused on the immediate story. Little was done to give a longer historical perspective on the crises in the mining industry. As such, they failed to situate Marikana within the context of colonialism and power struggles still dominating the South African mining industry.

Little space also seems to have been given to reporting the hearings themselves. Shorter news items were the order of the day. This seems to have been repeated once the report was released.

What has changed, if anything?

Seemingly, little has changed. Contextulisation of issues continues to be neglected.

This is by no means unique to the coverage of Marikana but a general feature of how labour disputes are covered by the South African news media.

This is also evident in the coverage of ongoing protests by communities over the delivery of basic services. This suggests that South African journalists have a poor functional understanding of conflict reporting.

In addition, news coverage points to a continuous anti-working class and anti-black bias. Journalists still struggle, or lack the will, to access affected communities and a broader stakeholder base. This might also boil down to a lack of resources.

Presenting a distorted picture

It is fair to say that the South African mainstream news media has created a rather limited, if not distorted view of Marikana. Proportionally, coverage has focused more on the violence of the strikes than fundamental problems underlining labour relations in South Africa.

As the Farlam Commission got underway, and with the release of the Commission’s report, there should have been a change. But there wasn’t. This points to the need to train journalists in sensitive conflict reporting.

Ylva Rodny-Gumede, Associate Professor of Journalism and Head of the Department of Journalism, Film and Television, University of Johannesburg

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

IMAGE: Church on Green Market Square in Cape Town, South Africa with a banner commemorating the Marikana massacre / Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0 International license

Tags: conflict reportingembedded journalistsMarikana massacreSouth African journalismUniversity of Johannesburgwar reportingYlva Rodny-Gumede

Ylva Rodny-Gumede

Ylva Rodny-Gumede 
is Associate Professor and Head of the Department of Journalism, Film and Television 
in the School of Communication 
at University of Johannesburg and a Senior Associate Researcher with the Stanhope Centre for International Communications Policy Research at the London School of Economics. Her current research concerns journalistic practices and models for journalism in post-colonial societies in the global South. Ylva holds a PhD from the School of Oriental and African Studies at London University and an MA in Politics from the University of Witwatersrand in Johannesburg, South Africa and an additional MA in Journalism from Cardiff University in the U.K.

Follow Us

  • twitter
  • threads
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Kelders van Geheime: The characters are here

Kelders van Geheime: The characters are here

March 22, 2024
Dissecting the LSM 7-10 market

Dissecting the LSM 7-10 market

May 17, 2023
Keri Miller sets the record straight after being axed from ECR

Keri Miller sets the record straight after being axed from ECR

April 23, 2023
Getting to know the ES SEMs 8-10 (Part 1)

Getting to know the ES SEMs 8-10 (Part 1)

February 22, 2018
Sowetan proves that sex still sells

Sowetan proves that sex still sells

105
It’s black. It’s beautiful. It’s ours.

Exclusive: Haffajee draws a line in the sand over racism

98
The Property Magazine and Media Nova go supernova

The Property Magazine and Media Nova go supernova

44
Warrant of arrest authorised for Media Nova’s Vaughan

Warrant of arrest authorised for Media Nova’s Vaughan

41
Seven Days on Social Media: Tonya’s in hospital, the nation’s in chaos and SA doesn’t care about Joshlin

Seven Days on Social Media: Tonya’s in hospital, the nation’s in chaos and SA doesn’t care about Joshlin

May 9, 2025
Social media platforms are replacing Google

Social media platforms are replacing Google

May 8, 2025
CMO to CEO​: 10 top tips from those who’ve done it

CMO to CEO​: 10 top tips from those who’ve done it

May 8, 2025
Media moves: Bonang’s House of BNG pops at launch, WPP launches empowerment initiative for women leaders in SA, MTF goes live

Media Moves: IAS off to AdForum, Lindsey Rayner new MD of Levergy, applications open for Digify Pro Online 2025

May 8, 2025

Recent News

Seven Days on Social Media: Tonya’s in hospital, the nation’s in chaos and SA doesn’t care about Joshlin

Seven Days on Social Media: Tonya’s in hospital, the nation’s in chaos and SA doesn’t care about Joshlin

May 9, 2025
Social media platforms are replacing Google

Social media platforms are replacing Google

May 8, 2025
CMO to CEO​: 10 top tips from those who’ve done it

CMO to CEO​: 10 top tips from those who’ve done it

May 8, 2025
Media moves: Bonang’s House of BNG pops at launch, WPP launches empowerment initiative for women leaders in SA, MTF goes live

Media Moves: IAS off to AdForum, Lindsey Rayner new MD of Levergy, applications open for Digify Pro Online 2025

May 8, 2025

ABOUT US

The Media Online is the definitive online point of reference for South Africa’s media industry offering relevant, focused and topical news on the media sector. We deliver up-to-date industry insights, guest columns, case studies, content from local and global contributors, news, views and interviews on a daily basis as well as providing an online home for The Media magazine’s content, which is posted on a monthly basis.

Follow Us

  • twitter
  • threads

ARENA HOLDING

Editor: Glenda Nevill
glenda.nevill@cybersmart.co.za
Sales and Advertising:
Tarin-Lee Watts
wattst@arena.africa
Download our rate card

OUR NETWORK

TimesLIVE
Sunday Times
SowetanLIVE
BusinessLIVE
Business Day
Financial Mail
HeraldLIVE
DispatchLIVE
Wanted Online
SA Home Owner
Business Media MAGS
Arena Events

NEWSLETTER SUBSCRIPTION

 
Subscribe
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

Copyright © 2015 - 2023 The Media Online. All rights reserved. Part of Arena Holdings (Pty) Ltd

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • MOST Awards
  • News
    • Awards
    • Media Mecca
  • Print
    • Newspapers
    • Magazines
    • Publishing
  • Broadcasting
    • TV
    • Radio
    • Cinema
    • Video
  • Digital
    • Mobile
    • Online
  • Agencies
    • Advertising
    • Media agency
    • Public Relations
  • OOH
    • Events
  • Research & Education
    • Research
    • Media Education
      • Media Mentor
  • Press Office
    • Press Office
    • TMO.Live Blog
    • Events
    • Jobs

Copyright © 2015 - 2023 The Media Online. All rights reserved. Part of Arena Holdings (Pty) Ltd

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?