• Subscribe to our newsletter
The Media Online
  • Home
  • MOST Awards
  • News
    • Awards
    • Media Mecca
  • Print
    • Newspapers
    • Magazines
    • Publishing
  • Broadcasting
    • TV
    • Radio
    • Cinema
    • Video
  • Digital
    • Mobile
    • Online
  • Agencies
    • Advertising
    • Media agency
    • Public Relations
  • OOH
    • Events
  • Research & Education
    • Research
    • Media Education
      • Media Mentor
  • Press Office
    • Press Office
    • TMO.Live Blog
    • Events
    • Jobs
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • MOST Awards
  • News
    • Awards
    • Media Mecca
  • Print
    • Newspapers
    • Magazines
    • Publishing
  • Broadcasting
    • TV
    • Radio
    • Cinema
    • Video
  • Digital
    • Mobile
    • Online
  • Agencies
    • Advertising
    • Media agency
    • Public Relations
  • OOH
    • Events
  • Research & Education
    • Research
    • Media Education
      • Media Mentor
  • Press Office
    • Press Office
    • TMO.Live Blog
    • Events
    • Jobs
No Result
View All Result
The Media Online
No Result
View All Result
Home News

Court dismisses Caxton challenge to massive print contract

by Antoinette Slabbert
March 2, 2018
in News
0 0
0
Court dismisses Caxton challenge to massive print contract
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The North Gauteng High Court on Wednesday dismissed with costs an application to set aside the biggest printing and distribution contract in the country.

This means that JSE-listed printing company Novus can continue to print millions of workbooks for 24 000 public schools until March 2020.

A Novus spokesperson welcomed the judgement.

The tender, which was challenged by CTP JV, in which Caxton’s CTP Limited is a major player, could be worth up to R3 billion.

Caxton said in response it is disappointed and has “issues with some of the conclusions reached in the judgment”. The group is “considering our position”, chairman Paul Jenkins told Moneyweb on Wednesday.

Moneyweb earlier reported that JSE-listed printing giants Caxton and Novus have been fighting over the lucrative deal since April 2016, when the National Treasury cancelled the original tender for school workbooks for the department of basic education. Bidders were called on to submit tenders for the printing, packaging and delivery of 60 million school workbooks for a period of three years, with a possible two-year extension.

The Lebone Consortium, in which Novus is a major player, got the award in March last year and has been executing it. The consortium, as well as the department of basic education (DBE), opposed the application.

Involved process

The contract comprises the printing of 60 million books with 8.78 billion pages in 11 official languages for learners in grades R to 9. These books have to be distributed to 24 000 schools in nine provinces. This happens in a cycle twice a year with printing taking place over 95 days and distribution over 35 days. The department calls it an “involved and intricate process”.

The CTP JV wanted the court to declare the tender award constitutionally invalid and set aside, to have it re-evaluated and to order Novus to repay all profits it has earned while the “unlawful” contract was running.

Judge John Murphy however dismissed the application with costs, including the cost of three counsel.

He dismissed CTP JV’s argument that the scoring and evaluation of its bid by the Bid Evaluation Committee (BEC) was unfair and that the two bids were treated unequally.

Murphy found that the BEC was permitted to depart from the approach mandated by the policy on reasonable grounds. He further found: “Judges must be careful not to usurp the functions of administrative agencies” and should be sensitive to their technical constraints.

He was not convinced that the BEC acted unreasonably or that its conduct gave rise to a reviewable irregularity.

Dismissed argument

Murphy dismissed the argument that the two bids were treated unequally. He accepted the argument that there was no need for the BEC to moderate the Lebone Consortium’s score on functionality, as it did with that of the CTP JV. Members reached early consensus that Lebone complied, but differed about CTP JV which necessitated further deliberations, he found.

He also rejected CTP JV’s argument that the director general of the DBE failed to comply with an obligation in an earlier court order by ignoring the legal opinion of advocate Ellis SC when he decided on the award. Ellis advised that the adjudication was irregular and unfair.

Murphy found that this is not a reviewable irregularity, since Ellis’s role was merely to advise.

Jenkins raised this finding as an example of its concerns with the ruling.

“As an example, it was a central point in Caxton’s (CTP JV’s) case that the Director General should have relied on the opinion of the court appointed independent senior advocate who was advising the tender adjudicators, that Caxton had been wrongly disqualified and must be admitted to the final round of adjudication.

“The Director General claimed he relied on a different opinion from another advocate, but the court found he had not given ‘an honest explanation’ and thus the criticism  that the Director General “has sought to mislead the court is troublingly well founded”.

Cost order

“It remains Caxton’s view that this aspect alone should have been determinative of the matter in Caxton’s favour,” Jenkins said.

Murphy further rejected CTP JV’s objection against a technical briefing the project manager Allan Subban gave ot the BEC. CTP JV argued it was in contravention with an earlier court order, but Murphy found the order only precluded DBE officials who were involved in previous attempts to award the contract from serving on the BEC, which Subban did not do.

Murphy ruled the application “wholly unsuccessful” and gave the cost order in the light of “the complexity of the matter, the length of the papers and the expedited time frames in which the papers and the argument had to be prepared; as well as the fact that all parties employed three counsel”.

A Novus spokesperson said the judgement validates the decision of the DBE to award the tender, for the printing and nationwide distribution of workbooks to its consortium.

“We look forward to continuing to make a meaningful contribution to education and learning for all South Africans through this excellent project and delivering uninterrupted supply of these school workbooks,” the spokesperson said.


This story was first published by Moneyweb (@Moneyweb) and is republished here with the permission of the editor.

Antoinette Slabbert has a passion for journalism, is incurably curious and loves asking questions for a living. She has specialised knowledge about the construction and energy sectors.


 

Tags: Antoinette SlabbertBECCaxtondepartment of basic educationLebone ConsortiumMoneywebNovusPaul Jenkinsprinting

Antoinette Slabbert

Antoinette Slabbert is Pretoria correspondent for Moneyweb. She has a passion for journalism, is incurably curious and loves asking questions for a living. She is writes about many subjects, but has specialised knowledge about the construction and energy sectors. She holds an honours degree in journalism and is currently also studying law. She was the winner of the Tourism Business Council Award for Excellence in Travel and Tourism Reporting in 2010. Follow her on Twitter @AntoinetteSlabb

Follow Us

  • twitter
  • threads
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Kelders van Geheime: The characters are here

Kelders van Geheime: The characters are here

March 22, 2024
Dissecting the LSM 7-10 market

Dissecting the LSM 7-10 market

May 17, 2023
Keri Miller sets the record straight after being axed from ECR

Keri Miller sets the record straight after being axed from ECR

April 23, 2023
Getting to know the ES SEMs 8-10 (Part 1)

Getting to know the ES SEMs 8-10 (Part 1)

February 22, 2018
Sowetan proves that sex still sells

Sowetan proves that sex still sells

105
It’s black. It’s beautiful. It’s ours.

Exclusive: Haffajee draws a line in the sand over racism

98
The Property Magazine and Media Nova go supernova

The Property Magazine and Media Nova go supernova

44
Warrant of arrest authorised for Media Nova’s Vaughan

Warrant of arrest authorised for Media Nova’s Vaughan

41
Social media platforms are replacing Google

Social media platforms are replacing Google

May 8, 2025
CMO to CEO​: 10 top tips from those who’ve done it

CMO to CEO​: 10 top tips from those who’ve done it

May 8, 2025
Media moves: Bonang’s House of BNG pops at launch, WPP launches empowerment initiative for women leaders in SA, MTF goes live

Media Moves: IAS off to AdForum, Lindsey Rayner new MD of Levergy, applications open for Digify Pro Online 2025

May 8, 2025
Crisis Comms 101: Don’t just run to the lawyers

Crisis Comms 101: Don’t just run to the lawyers

May 7, 2025

Recent News

Social media platforms are replacing Google

Social media platforms are replacing Google

May 8, 2025
CMO to CEO​: 10 top tips from those who’ve done it

CMO to CEO​: 10 top tips from those who’ve done it

May 8, 2025
Media moves: Bonang’s House of BNG pops at launch, WPP launches empowerment initiative for women leaders in SA, MTF goes live

Media Moves: IAS off to AdForum, Lindsey Rayner new MD of Levergy, applications open for Digify Pro Online 2025

May 8, 2025
Crisis Comms 101: Don’t just run to the lawyers

Crisis Comms 101: Don’t just run to the lawyers

May 7, 2025

ABOUT US

The Media Online is the definitive online point of reference for South Africa’s media industry offering relevant, focused and topical news on the media sector. We deliver up-to-date industry insights, guest columns, case studies, content from local and global contributors, news, views and interviews on a daily basis as well as providing an online home for The Media magazine’s content, which is posted on a monthly basis.

Follow Us

  • twitter
  • threads

ARENA HOLDING

Editor: Glenda Nevill
glenda.nevill@cybersmart.co.za
Sales and Advertising:
Tarin-Lee Watts
wattst@arena.africa
Download our rate card

OUR NETWORK

TimesLIVE
Sunday Times
SowetanLIVE
BusinessLIVE
Business Day
Financial Mail
HeraldLIVE
DispatchLIVE
Wanted Online
SA Home Owner
Business Media MAGS
Arena Events

NEWSLETTER SUBSCRIPTION

 
Subscribe
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

Copyright © 2015 - 2023 The Media Online. All rights reserved. Part of Arena Holdings (Pty) Ltd

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • MOST Awards
  • News
    • Awards
    • Media Mecca
  • Print
    • Newspapers
    • Magazines
    • Publishing
  • Broadcasting
    • TV
    • Radio
    • Cinema
    • Video
  • Digital
    • Mobile
    • Online
  • Agencies
    • Advertising
    • Media agency
    • Public Relations
  • OOH
    • Events
  • Research & Education
    • Research
    • Media Education
      • Media Mentor
  • Press Office
    • Press Office
    • TMO.Live Blog
    • Events
    • Jobs

Copyright © 2015 - 2023 The Media Online. All rights reserved. Part of Arena Holdings (Pty) Ltd

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?