• Subscribe to our newsletter
The Media Online
  • Home
  • MOST Awards
  • News
    • Awards
    • Media Mecca
  • Print
    • Newspapers
    • Magazines
    • Publishing
  • Broadcasting
    • TV
    • Radio
    • Cinema
    • Video
  • Digital
    • Mobile
    • Online
  • Agencies
    • Advertising
    • Media agency
    • Public Relations
  • OOH
    • Events
  • Research & Education
    • Research
    • Media Education
      • Media Mentor
  • Press Office
    • Press Office
    • TMO.Live Blog
    • Events
    • Jobs
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • MOST Awards
  • News
    • Awards
    • Media Mecca
  • Print
    • Newspapers
    • Magazines
    • Publishing
  • Broadcasting
    • TV
    • Radio
    • Cinema
    • Video
  • Digital
    • Mobile
    • Online
  • Agencies
    • Advertising
    • Media agency
    • Public Relations
  • OOH
    • Events
  • Research & Education
    • Research
    • Media Education
      • Media Mentor
  • Press Office
    • Press Office
    • TMO.Live Blog
    • Events
    • Jobs
No Result
View All Result
The Media Online
No Result
View All Result
Home News Media business

News industry meltdown: Market failure or creative destruction?

While not as clear-cut as roads, clean water, and air, the democratic value to society of public interest journalism is, in my book and many others, a public good.

by Styli Charalambous
April 15, 2024
in Media business
0 0
0
News industry meltdown: Market failure or creative destruction?
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Yes, news media scored many own goals, but it has crucial role to play in society – and cannot go unsupported.

The recent tsunami of bad news about the news has raised an interesting question. Are we seeing the effects of a market failure playing out, or are we seeing the death of an industry that failed to innovate and keep up with the times?

Styli Charalambous

“Creative destruction” was coined by economist Joseph Schumpeter in 1942 to describe the dismantling of established processes to make way for new ones.

A bitter and uncomfortable shedding of deadweight, as new products or technologies lead to the demise of the old ones.

Think of camera film and Kodak, the often-studied business school case study of product disruption. Few tears were shed as the world embraced digital cameras and smartphones because digital photography was easier, cheaper and better.

Prof Jay Rosen summarised many things that contributed to where we find ourselves — showing how we scored many own goals. Is journalism past its sell-by date, as some have argued? And does it matter whether it’s a market failure instead?

Here are some thoughts.

Scenario playing out

First, it is important to distinguish which scenario is playing out. Mostly because, if we are indeed seeing market failure, the best and usually only response is for regulatory intervention and government support.

If it’s a plain vanilla disruption of the Kodak kind, we will see new products and services fill the void of journalism, and society will be better off. Societies and democracies shouldn’t decay, migrating from the news equivalent of camera film to digital.

It’s also important to separate the newspaper segment of the industry from broadcast news on television and radio. Studies have shown that these newsrooms provide more original news reporting than any other over time, and are probably responsible for most groundbreaking investigations that change our world.

Yet, they are the ones that have suffered the most financially.

Pew Research: Comparing Newspaper Employment to Other News

Market failure argument

The argument for market failure hinges on the idea that public service journalism, especially local and investigative reporting, is a public good, underprovided in a broken market system.

Anyone following the turmoil of the last 20 years will know that the digital revolution has severely disrupted the economics of the news industry. Advertising revenue, once the lifeblood of the industry, has massively shifted to tech giants like Google and Facebook, leaving news outlets gasping for sustainable revenue models.

This could be seen as a failure of the market to support vital democratic functions of the press, such as holding power to account and informing the public.

Additionally, the proliferation of free content online has led to a devaluation of quality journalism in the eyes of many consumers, who might not differentiate between well-researched, fact-checked reporting and more sensationalist or biased content.

Or a TikTok created in a teenager’s bedroom.

This could be seen as a market failure where consumers do not adequately value a crucial product for democracy, but it is still valuable and sorely needed.

Adding an extra layer of complexity is when a few players (ala New York Times, Financial Times, etc.) are winning. “Winner takes most” is a common theme in news industry reports, epitomising the problem where a global publisher like New York Times is seen as a competitor for local news subscription budgets.

Journalism as a public good

The other element of the market failure argument is whether journalism is a “public good.” Usually, public goods are provided by governments, are not for exclusive use and can be used multiple times.

The South African National Editor’s Forum settled on a definition that ‘public interest journalism’ refers to journalistic activity that is central to the democratic function and the protection and promotion of the South African Constitution, including investigative journalism, reporting on the daily affairs of public institutions, and local journalism focused on the generation of public interest stories in towns and villages and underserviced rural areas.

So, while not all journalism is a public good, much journalism is created in the public interest and can be argued as such. While not as clear-cut as roads, clean water, and air, the democratic value to society of public interest journalism is, in my book and many others, a public good.

Creative disruption argument

On the flipside, the argument for creative disruption posits that the challenges faced by the news industry are a natural part of technological advancement and evolution within the media landscape.

Prof Jeff Jarvis asks if it’s time to give up on old news because “legacy” journalism has failed to become a service to society and be driven by the needs of those audiences they claim to serve.

From this perspective, the internet and digital platforms have democratised content creation and distribution, breaking down the barriers that once kept news media as gatekeepers of information. This has led to an explosion of new voices and perspectives, arguably enriching the public discourse.

Shifting business models towards digital reader revenue, subscription, membership, and crowdfunding are emerging as news organisations adapt to this new environment, albeit with few success stories.

This can be seen as a healthy, albeit painful, transformation that pushes the industry towards more direct and engaging relationships with its audience, fostering loyalty and community.

The follow-up question is: at what cost to society? When Kodak and other camera film manufacturers developed their last negatives, society was unchanged, and many would argue that society was better off. Can we say the same if the news industry continues to haemorrhage in the way it has?

So which is it?

My deduction is both. But much more of one.

Poor leadership, failure to innovate and clinging to old practices have certainly factored into the demise of many news outlets. Not to mention those who operate in the extremes of the attention economy, seeking to monetise our anger and fears.

But many news practitioners are doing incredible work in heart-breaking conditions and getting nowhere, thanks to economics that no longer work.

If we agree that the system is broken and that there is still immense value to society for that product/service, regulatory intervention is the only response that can restore a semblance of normalcy.

These take the form of incentives and subsidies to encourage behaviour changes from members of the public, advertisers and publishers themselves.

I write about these possible measures in detail here, taking guidance from successful European efforts, sustainability research reports and other government-supported industries.

They include:

 Some regulatory measures and incentives to sustain media

For some, government intervention might sound scary, but there are many examples where it can and has been done in a supportive and helpful way.

There are many precedents we can lean on and measures that can prevent systemic abuse. In 2009, the Federal Trade Commission in the USA held discussions with industry players around policy recommendations to support the “reinvention of journalism” in the Internet age. “Market failure” was already bandied about then, and some of the recommendations look quite appealing when viewed through the lens of an extinction-level event.

In countries where subsidies exist, like those in Scandinavia, we also find high press freedom scores and stellar corruption perception scores. More importantly, we see some of the healthiest news media organisations in the world. Regulatory support is not the only factor, but it is surely significant during periods of mass disruption to provide the space for innovation.

Those practising public service journalism feel very much like Sisyphus — destined to push boulders up never-ending mountains. We don’t need any more proof that the system is broken; we need supportive measures for a critical industry. Now.

*This story was first published on Medium.

As co-founder and CEO of Daily Maverick, Styli Charalambous is responsible for driving business model innovation, data and technology adoption and membership. But mostly making sure people get paid. He earned start-up stripes and grey hair along the way in other ventures and is now a reformed accountant.


CLICK ON THE COVER TO READY THE MEDIA YEARBOOK 2024


 

Tags: advertisingDaily Maverickfunding journalisminvestigative journalismjournalismmediamedia businessmonetisationnews platformsnewspaperspresspublic goodpublishingStyli Charalamboussubscriberssubscription

Styli Charalambous

Styli Charalambous is the CEO of the Daily Maverick, having joined the dynamic publisher in the build-up to launching in 2009. A chartered accountant by profession, Charalambous overseas all the commercial aspects of running the Daily Maverick, with a very hands-on approach. He has also been known to assist with some economic editorial articles or controversial opinion pieces. More than anything, he is passionate about the Daily Maverick and the waves its making in media.

Follow Us

  • twitter
  • threads
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Kelders van Geheime: The characters are here

Kelders van Geheime: The characters are here

March 22, 2024
Dissecting the LSM 7-10 market

Dissecting the LSM 7-10 market

May 17, 2023
Keri Miller sets the record straight after being axed from ECR

Keri Miller sets the record straight after being axed from ECR

April 23, 2023
Getting to know the ES SEMs 8-10 (Part 1)

Getting to know the ES SEMs 8-10 (Part 1)

February 22, 2018
Sowetan proves that sex still sells

Sowetan proves that sex still sells

105
It’s black. It’s beautiful. It’s ours.

Exclusive: Haffajee draws a line in the sand over racism

98
The Property Magazine and Media Nova go supernova

The Property Magazine and Media Nova go supernova

44
Warrant of arrest authorised for Media Nova’s Vaughan

Warrant of arrest authorised for Media Nova’s Vaughan

41
Social media platforms are replacing Google

Social media platforms are replacing Google

May 8, 2025
CMO to CEO​: 10 top tips from those who’ve done it

CMO to CEO​: 10 top tips from those who’ve done it

May 8, 2025
Media moves: Bonang’s House of BNG pops at launch, WPP launches empowerment initiative for women leaders in SA, MTF goes live

Media Moves: IAS off to AdForum, Lindsey Rayner new MD of Levergy, applications open for Digify Pro Online 2025

May 8, 2025
Crisis Comms 101: Don’t just run to the lawyers

Crisis Comms 101: Don’t just run to the lawyers

May 7, 2025

Recent News

Social media platforms are replacing Google

Social media platforms are replacing Google

May 8, 2025
CMO to CEO​: 10 top tips from those who’ve done it

CMO to CEO​: 10 top tips from those who’ve done it

May 8, 2025
Media moves: Bonang’s House of BNG pops at launch, WPP launches empowerment initiative for women leaders in SA, MTF goes live

Media Moves: IAS off to AdForum, Lindsey Rayner new MD of Levergy, applications open for Digify Pro Online 2025

May 8, 2025
Crisis Comms 101: Don’t just run to the lawyers

Crisis Comms 101: Don’t just run to the lawyers

May 7, 2025

ABOUT US

The Media Online is the definitive online point of reference for South Africa’s media industry offering relevant, focused and topical news on the media sector. We deliver up-to-date industry insights, guest columns, case studies, content from local and global contributors, news, views and interviews on a daily basis as well as providing an online home for The Media magazine’s content, which is posted on a monthly basis.

Follow Us

  • twitter
  • threads

ARENA HOLDING

Editor: Glenda Nevill
glenda.nevill@cybersmart.co.za
Sales and Advertising:
Tarin-Lee Watts
wattst@arena.africa
Download our rate card

OUR NETWORK

TimesLIVE
Sunday Times
SowetanLIVE
BusinessLIVE
Business Day
Financial Mail
HeraldLIVE
DispatchLIVE
Wanted Online
SA Home Owner
Business Media MAGS
Arena Events

NEWSLETTER SUBSCRIPTION

 
Subscribe
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

Copyright © 2015 - 2023 The Media Online. All rights reserved. Part of Arena Holdings (Pty) Ltd

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • MOST Awards
  • News
    • Awards
    • Media Mecca
  • Print
    • Newspapers
    • Magazines
    • Publishing
  • Broadcasting
    • TV
    • Radio
    • Cinema
    • Video
  • Digital
    • Mobile
    • Online
  • Agencies
    • Advertising
    • Media agency
    • Public Relations
  • OOH
    • Events
  • Research & Education
    • Research
    • Media Education
      • Media Mentor
  • Press Office
    • Press Office
    • TMO.Live Blog
    • Events
    • Jobs

Copyright © 2015 - 2023 The Media Online. All rights reserved. Part of Arena Holdings (Pty) Ltd

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?