• Subscribe to our newsletter
The Media Online
  • Home
  • MOST Awards
  • News
    • Awards
    • Media Mecca
  • Print
    • Newspapers
    • Magazines
    • Publishing
  • Broadcasting
    • TV
    • Radio
    • Cinema
    • Video
  • Digital
    • Mobile
    • Online
  • Agencies
    • Advertising
    • Media agency
    • Public Relations
  • OOH
    • Events
  • Research & Education
    • Research
    • Media Education
      • Media Mentor
  • Press Office
    • Press Office
    • TMO.Live Blog
    • Events
    • Jobs
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • MOST Awards
  • News
    • Awards
    • Media Mecca
  • Print
    • Newspapers
    • Magazines
    • Publishing
  • Broadcasting
    • TV
    • Radio
    • Cinema
    • Video
  • Digital
    • Mobile
    • Online
  • Agencies
    • Advertising
    • Media agency
    • Public Relations
  • OOH
    • Events
  • Research & Education
    • Research
    • Media Education
      • Media Mentor
  • Press Office
    • Press Office
    • TMO.Live Blog
    • Events
    • Jobs
No Result
View All Result
The Media Online
No Result
View All Result
Home Communications Opinion

Competition Commission’s price fixing settlement with Corpcom raises critical questions

by Bra Willy Seyama
November 30, 2022
in Opinion
0 0
0
Competition Commission’s price fixing settlement with Corpcom raises critical questions
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The Competition Commission announced on Thursday 18 November 2022 that media firm Corpcom Outdoor (Pty) Ltd, which was subsequently bought by JCDecaux, has been ordered by the Competition Tribunal to pay a penalty of R1.38 million, plus R500 198 to the Economic Development Fund.

This was as a settlement related to the price fixing finding against it. Given that the membership of the Black Agencies Network Association (BANA) includes black-owned out-of-home (OOH) media owners and media agencies, we find it relevant to give an opinion on this matter.

Following an investigation since 2011, the Commission found that Corpcom, among other companies in the marketing, advertising and communications (MAC) industries, engaged in practices that included, among others, agreements to offer similar discounts and payment terms to advertising agencies that place advertisements with Media Credit Co-ordinators (MCC) accredited members, whereas non-accredited advertising agencies received smaller discounts.

This ruling and settlement agreement serves as a deterrent to such practices, but also raises at least three critical questions and concerns:

Why did it take so long to settle this case – 11 years?

Is the Commission making a material difference in the MAC industry by ordering such settlement agreements through the Tribunal?

How should the Commission tackle anti-competitive behaviour going forward?


Read more: Of competition, collusion, cartels and corporate leniency

Read more: Tick tock… Black-owned media SMMEs await news on MDDA’s Economic Development Fund

Read more: Media houses guilty of price-fixing, fixing of trading conditions – Competition Commission

Read more: ‘MDDA is the most suitable agency to oversee our empowerment fund’ – Competition Commission


Pertaining to the first question, the transformation aims of the Commission are captured in its mission to “play a role in ensuring a vibrant economy and economic growth”; to undertake “competition regulation for a growing and inclusive economy”; which “entails adopting a dynamic view to enforcement, considering both immediate and long-term implications of the Commission’s decisions on the economy”.

Bra Willy Seyama

As such, the mission is partly achieved through punitive measures against (often large and previously advantaged) delinquent companies, and that should serve as a deterrent against anti-competitive behaviours. However, these measures are thwarted if it takes so long to conclude cases that go against these transformation ideals. This state of affairs brings to mind the cautionary proverb, “justice delayed, is justice denied”.

The second question addresses the efficacy of the Commission’s approach to price fixing, by way of punitive measures and settlement agreements, within the context of the MAC sector. There are material and real time financial implications for a protracted investigative process. The penalty of R1.38 million for a price fixing case that took 11 years to conclude has lost close to 40% of its value by now, calculated at an average of 4.5% annual inflation over the same period. Clearly then, the financial impact of the punitive measure is lost!

If one considers that the Black Billboard Owners Alliance (BBOA) reports on their website that their members get only a tiny slice of the OOH business, estimated at R1.452 billion in 2019, it is apparent that systemic collusion has real time financial implications. As a result, the BBOA declares that it aims “to fight and change the status quo and inequalities regarding OOH Media in South Africa for our generation and the next”.

This is not a fight to gain privileges in the industry, but to secure the bare minimum for historically disadvantaged sections of the population and equity all-round. For example, an article published in the Mail & Guardian in 2019, titled, ‘Who runs SA’s media is a black-and-white issue‘, claims, “The media is not unlike many companies in the country; it’s run mostly by white people. An analysis of ownership structures, demographics and funding models shows that the boards of media houses comprise 41% white, 24% African, 17% coloured, 16% Indian and 2% of people from elsewhere.”

These are empirical facts that cannot be denied and should not be evaded if substantive economic equality is to be achieved.

It is our view that this anti-competitive behaviour is continuing in the MAC industry in this day and age, taking different shapes and forms, as attempts are made to operate within the letter of the transformation laws, but certainly not in the spirit of these laws! Here are two examples of such practices that BANA plans to request the Commission to investigate in the near future:

  • The existing advertising and media groups in the MAC industry are basically set up to “keep it in the family” by ensuring that lucrative accounts are circulated among companies that are part of such groups.
  • The second example involves attainment of favourable BBBEE scores by some of the MAC agencies, assisted by consultants to circumvent the country’s transformation laws, without much meaningful change in the ownership structures.

The final question seeks a proactive way forward in terms of how the Commission could tackle anti-competitive behaviour.

The way the world-renowned Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC), launched in 1995, was conducted, involved both the perpetrators of heinous racially motivated crimes and the victims. We are aware that there are all sorts of ongoing debates about the TRC’s outcomes and the effectiveness of associated restitutional modalities.

That debate falls out of the scope of the issue at hand. Rather, we believe that black-owned companies, which are most affected by anti-transformation behaviours in the South African economy, must be involved when such cases are investigated by the Commission and prosecuted by the Tribunal.

This is in order to provide insight and evidence of the real-life impact of such practices that exact a heavy cost on society, as a result of the skewed economic activities, borne out of this wayward behaviour. It only makes sense that the victims must be involved as part of the investigations and prosecutions.

In the context of the MAC industry, BANA and BBOA are ready and willing to represent their constituencies if invited to participate in the relevant proceedings.

Yes, we know that the Commission will not launch any investigations without a complaint being lodged by a player in a said economic sector, or a member of the public. However, it must not end there. The adversely affected group of players in the relevant industry must be invited to give evidence, to give impetus to the investigations, and to assist in determining appropriate punitive measures.

There is no doubt in our minds that the adversely affected businesses will generally be Black-owned, in many of the investigated cases. This particular case of the anti-transformation behaviour by a segment of the OOH industry is a classic example.

Bra Willy Seyama is a founding member of the Black Agency Network Association, BANA.


 

 

Tags: advertisingagenciesanti-competitive behaviourBANABlack Agency Network Associationblack-owned agenciesBra Willy SemeyaCompetition CommissionCorpcomcreative agencyMCCmediamedia agencyMedia Credit Co-ordinatorsout of home advertisingsettlement

Bra Willy Seyama

Bra Willy Seyama is founder & chief explorations officer of eNitiate – a Pan African data-driven digital content marketing solutions company that has been in operation for more than 13 years. He is also one of the founding members of BANA. Bra Willy is better known for his love for analysing digital data coming up with useful insights and publishing them in the eNitiate blog, which can be found on this link: https://enitiate.solutions/blog/

Follow Us

  • twitter
  • threads
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Kelders van Geheime: The characters are here

Kelders van Geheime: The characters are here

March 22, 2024
Dissecting the LSM 7-10 market

Dissecting the LSM 7-10 market

May 17, 2023
Keri Miller sets the record straight after being axed from ECR

Keri Miller sets the record straight after being axed from ECR

April 23, 2023
Getting to know the ES SEMs 8-10 (Part 1)

Getting to know the ES SEMs 8-10 (Part 1)

February 22, 2018
Sowetan proves that sex still sells

Sowetan proves that sex still sells

105
It’s black. It’s beautiful. It’s ours.

Exclusive: Haffajee draws a line in the sand over racism

98
The Property Magazine and Media Nova go supernova

The Property Magazine and Media Nova go supernova

44
Warrant of arrest authorised for Media Nova’s Vaughan

Warrant of arrest authorised for Media Nova’s Vaughan

41
AI in sponsorship: Beyond the buzzword

AI in sponsorship: Beyond the buzzword

May 9, 2025
Upping the ante: Tracking the year-on-year growth of gambling in SA

Upping the ante: Tracking the year-on-year growth of gambling in SA

May 9, 2025
Seven Days on Social Media: Tonya’s in hospital, the nation’s in chaos and SA doesn’t care about Joshlin

Seven Days on Social Media: Tonya’s in hospital, the nation’s in chaos and SA doesn’t care about Joshlin

May 9, 2025
Social media platforms are replacing Google

Social media platforms are replacing Google

May 8, 2025

Recent News

AI in sponsorship: Beyond the buzzword

AI in sponsorship: Beyond the buzzword

May 9, 2025
Upping the ante: Tracking the year-on-year growth of gambling in SA

Upping the ante: Tracking the year-on-year growth of gambling in SA

May 9, 2025
Seven Days on Social Media: Tonya’s in hospital, the nation’s in chaos and SA doesn’t care about Joshlin

Seven Days on Social Media: Tonya’s in hospital, the nation’s in chaos and SA doesn’t care about Joshlin

May 9, 2025
Social media platforms are replacing Google

Social media platforms are replacing Google

May 8, 2025

ABOUT US

The Media Online is the definitive online point of reference for South Africa’s media industry offering relevant, focused and topical news on the media sector. We deliver up-to-date industry insights, guest columns, case studies, content from local and global contributors, news, views and interviews on a daily basis as well as providing an online home for The Media magazine’s content, which is posted on a monthly basis.

Follow Us

  • twitter
  • threads

ARENA HOLDING

Editor: Glenda Nevill
glenda.nevill@cybersmart.co.za
Sales and Advertising:
Tarin-Lee Watts
wattst@arena.africa
Download our rate card

OUR NETWORK

TimesLIVE
Sunday Times
SowetanLIVE
BusinessLIVE
Business Day
Financial Mail
HeraldLIVE
DispatchLIVE
Wanted Online
SA Home Owner
Business Media MAGS
Arena Events

NEWSLETTER SUBSCRIPTION

 
Subscribe
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Privacy & Policy
  • Contact

Copyright © 2015 - 2023 The Media Online. All rights reserved. Part of Arena Holdings (Pty) Ltd

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • MOST Awards
  • News
    • Awards
    • Media Mecca
  • Print
    • Newspapers
    • Magazines
    • Publishing
  • Broadcasting
    • TV
    • Radio
    • Cinema
    • Video
  • Digital
    • Mobile
    • Online
  • Agencies
    • Advertising
    • Media agency
    • Public Relations
  • OOH
    • Events
  • Research & Education
    • Research
    • Media Education
      • Media Mentor
  • Press Office
    • Press Office
    • TMO.Live Blog
    • Events
    • Jobs

Copyright © 2015 - 2023 The Media Online. All rights reserved. Part of Arena Holdings (Pty) Ltd

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?